
Quick Answer: Visitor management without a security guard works when every visitor can reach the right flat directly and residents can verify and let them in remotely. A QR-code video intercom such as DoorVi does this: the visitor scans a QR at the gate, video-calls the resident from their own phone, and the resident unlocks remotely, with every visit logged.
Millions of urban Indians live in buildings too small for a gated-society setup: builder floors in Delhi-NCR, 8–20 flat standalone buildings in Noida, Pune and Bengaluru, and independent houses rented floor by floor. They usually have no guard, no working intercom, and a shared gate that stays either locked (so residents keep running down) or open (so anyone walks in).
At the same time, the number of people ringing that gate has exploded. According to Datum Intelligence figures reported by TechCrunch in August 2026, Blinkit alone handles roughly 3.4–3.6 million orders a day and Zepto about 2.4–2.6 million. That's before food delivery, couriers, cooks, drivers and guests.
The usual fix, hiring a guard, is expensive for a small building. Delhi's minimum wage for unskilled workers is ₹18,456 a month from 1 April 2026 (ClearTax). Round-the-clock cover needs three shifts, so a 12-flat building pays at least ₹55,368 a month (about ₹4,600 per flat) before agency margins, leave cover and uniforms.
That's why "How does a building stay secure if there is no security guard in it?" keeps coming up on Quora. The honest answer: you move identity checks and entry decisions to the resident's phone.
Take a real-world type of building: a 12-flat, four-storey standalone block in Noida. It has one gate with an electric lock, a broken wired intercom, and no guard. Arvind is the volunteer RWA secretary. Priya lives on the 3rd floor and works hybrid.
The rider never sees Priya's phone number. DoorVi hides it unless the resident explicitly turns on "Callback Number."
Many small buildings have a part-time watchman or a shared chowkidar for the lane. DoorVi supports mixed entry modes (QR-only, Guard + QR, or Tablet + Reception), so a watchman can use the Guard Doorman app when he's on duty and the QR flow covers the other hours. With resident-to-guard calling and building broadcast, residents can reach him, and Arvind can send notices ("Water tank cleaning at 11 am") to every flat at once.
| DoorVi | MyGate | NoBrokerHood | ADDA GateKeeper | Wired video door phone (e.g., Godrej) | Hired guard | |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Hardware needed | QR sign; optional tablet; relay for remote unlock | Gate device running guard app | Gate device for security staff | Tablet at the security gate | Outdoor panel + indoor monitor per flat | None (a person) |
| Installation / wiring | No intercom wiring; relay on existing lock | App install; no wiring | App install; no wiring | App install; no wiring | Cabling to every flat | None |
| Cost model | QR tags from ₹499; building plans quote-based | Quote-based (third-party estimates ₹20–50/flat/month) | Free basic tier + paid subscription | Free trial (250 entries), then quote-based | Hardware from ₹15,999 per unit + installation | ₹18,456+/month per shift (Delhi minimum wage) |
| Works with no guard present? | Yes, designed for self-serve | Built around a guard validating entries | Built around security personnel at the gate | Built around app at security gate | Yes, but only rings flats inside | n/a |
| Visitor needs an app? | No | No (guard handles entry) | No | No | No | No |
| Remote unlock when away | Yes, from the app via relay/integration | Via guard | Via guard | Via guard | Usually only from indoor monitor | Via phone call to guard |
| Access-control integrations | PDK, Brivo, Mobgate, Intelbras, igloohome, relays | Check with vendor | Check with vendor | Check with vendor | Brand ecosystem | n/a |
| Best for | 4–50 flat buildings, builder floors, offices without staff | Large gated societies with guards | Societies wanting a free-to-start community app | Societies already on ADDA ERP | Single homes wanting an indoor screen | High-risk or very large sites |
Already using MyGate? You don't have to choose. A society can keep MyGate and its guard at the main gate and add DoorVi with a relay, PDK or Brivo lock at each tower lobby door. Visitors are cleared at the gate, then call the flat from the lobby QR, and the resident unlocks the lobby door from their phone. No guard is needed at every lobby (how MyGate societies automate lobby doors).
Sources: MyGate visitor management, Techjockey on MyGate charges, NoBrokerHood FAQ, NoBrokerHood gate entry, ADDA GateKeeper, Godrej Security Solutions shop, ClearTax. Prices checked September 2026. Confirm with each vendor.
If you're a 300+ flat gated society with a full security team and you want billing, accounting, facility booking and helpdesk in one ERP, MyGate, NoBrokerHood or ADDA may fit better as your main platform. If you only want an indoor screen in a single independent house and don't need remote access, a wired video door phone is a reasonable one-time purchase. And if your site has had break-ins or has high-value assets, a trained guard plus CCTV is still worth the money. Technology supports human security there. It doesn't replace it.
Assumptions: 12 flats, one gate with an existing electric lock, 2026 prices. The DoorVi building plan is quote-based, so get an actual quote.
| Option | Upfront | Monthly | Year-1 total | Per flat / month (yr 1) |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 24x7 guard (3 shifts at Delhi unskilled minimum wage) | ₹0 | ₹55,368 | ₹6,64,416 | ~₹4,614 |
| Wired video door phones (assume ₹16,000/unit + ₹30,000 cabling) | ~₹2,22,000 | ~₹0 | ~₹2,22,000 | ~₹1,542 |
| DoorVi QR + relay (assume ₹5,000 relay + electrician; building plan: quote-based) | ~₹5,000 | DoorVi plan | ₹5,000 + plan | Plan cost + ~₹35 |
Even if DoorVi's building plan cost several thousand rupees a month, the building would still save lakhs a year compared with a 24x7 guard. It also avoids the one-time outlay for a wired intercom, and residents get remote unlock that a wired intercom usually doesn't offer.
India notified the Digital Personal Data Protection Rules on 13 November 2025. The substantive obligations, including consent and breach notification, apply from May 2027 (S&R Associates). RWAs that collect visitor names, phone numbers and photos should collect only what they need, set retention rules, and prefer systems that don't expose residents' numbers to visitors. Speak to your legal adviser for specific compliance advice.
Yes, for most small residential buildings, as long as the gate stays locked and only residents can let people in. A QR video intercom lets each resident see and speak to visitors before unlocking. Every entry is logged. Buildings with high-value assets or past incidents should still consider a guard plus CCTV.
No. Visitors scan the QR code with any smartphone camera and start a video call right away. Only residents and admins use the DoorVi app.
Residents can give expected visitors a six-digit guest code or a pre-approval pass. Buildings with a watchman can also use Guard + QR mode or a tablet at the entrance.
Yes. When the gate lock is connected through a compatible relay or access-control integration, residents can tap unlock in the DoorVi app from anywhere with internet.
No. DoorVi doesn't show a resident's number to the person scanning the QR unless the resident turns on the "Callback Number" option.
No. There's no cabling to each flat. You only connect a small relay to the existing lock or gate motor if you want remote unlock.
MyGate and NoBrokerHood are society-management platforms built around a guard or security staff at the gate. DoorVi is a QR-code video intercom that lets visitors reach residents directly and opens doors through a relay, PDK or Brivo, so it also works where there's no guard. Many societies can use both: MyGate at the main gate and DoorVi at tower lobby doors.
Individual DoorVi QR tags start at ₹499 on the DoorVi shop, and a basic plan is free. Pricing for multi-flat buildings is quote-based. Book a demo for a quote.
Small buildings don't need a ₹55,000-a-month guard to know who's at the gate. They need a way for every visitor to reach the right flat, and for the right person to decide, from wherever they are. That's what DoorVi does with a QR code, a phone and a relay on the lock you already have. Book a free 15-minute DoorVi demo or get a DoorVi QR tag and try it on your gate this week.
By Sachin Gupta, Director, DoorVi. Sachin leads DoorVi's visitor-management and access-control work across India, Brazil, the US and the UAE, helping properties replace wired intercoms with QR-based video entry.
Last updated: 11 October 2026